What Goes Up: The Returns Reality Behind Record Holiday Spending

The holiday shopping season delivered exactly what retailers hoped for: packed stores, full digital shopping carts, and spending numbers that exceeded projections. Cyber Week– the five-day stretch from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday– saw consumer spending increase 7.7% compared to last year, while a record 202.9 million Americans opened their wallets during the period, up from 197 million in 2023.

A More Strategic Shopper Emerges

Today’s consumers arrived armed with deal alerts and price-comparison apps, demonstrating a laser focus on value and deep discounts. This wasn’t the carefree, impulse-driven shopping of years past. The days of casual browsing turning into spontaneous purchases have given way to strategic, intentional buying behavior shaped by economic uncertainty and inflation fatigue.

Where Shoppers Actually Spent

The channel shift continues to reshape retail’s landscape. While 129.5 million shoppers made their way to physical stores, marking a 3% increase, the real action happened online, where sales climbed to $79.6 billion, making a 5% jump from last year. Online shopping now accounts for 30% of total holiday sales, a figure that confirms the pandemic’s lasting impact on how we shop.

Retailers navigated this season with skill, managing lean inventories in response to both an uncertain economy and the unpredictable tariff environment. The strategy paid off during the recent sales surge, but it sets the stage for what comes next: the inevitable wave of returns that follows every holiday season.

The $160 Billion Returns Reality

Approximately 17% of all those carefully wrapped holiday gifts will make their way back to stores and distribution centers. We’re talking about $160 billion in returned merchandise, a huge figure that represents one of retail’s most challenging operational realities.

The returns landscape has fundamentally changed. Return rates have more than doubled since 2019, driven largely by the explosion in online shopping. While overall return rates hover around 17%, online purchases tell a different story, with over 19% coming back and a return volume reaching between $50 billion and $60 billion. For online apparel, the numbers grow even more, with return rates approaching 30% as customers effectively use their homes as fitting rooms.

The Hidden Cost of Returns

The financial impact extends far beyond simply restocking shelves. Processing a return typically costs retailers around 30% of an item’s original price, with low-cost items eating up an even larger percentage of their value. Those costs add up fast, cutting into the holiday profits retailers just celebrated. And perhaps even more concerning for long-term business health: 71% of consumers say they’re less likely to shop with a retailer again after a poor returns experience, making the stakes of managing returns and excess inventory about far more than just operational efficiency.

Preparing for the Post-Holiday Surge

As the largest B2B resale platform handling returns and excess merchandise for nine of the top 10 retailers, B-Stock sits at the epicenter of this post-holiday tsunami. Our data tells the story clearly: Q1 typically brings a 20-30% surge in inventory flowing through our platform, with approximately 60% consisting of customer returns, compared to 40% from excess inventory and shelf pulls during other quarters.

As retailers face mounting pressure to balance strong sales with sustainable operations, the ability to efficiently process, resell, and recoup value from excess merchandise becomes not just operationally critical, but strategically essential. The holiday shopping season may grab headlines with its record-breaking numbers, but for retail operations teams, the real work is just beginning.

Ready to turn post-holiday returns into recovered revenue? Download our annual holiday playbook for comprehensive data, actionable insights, and proven best practices that help retailers, brands, and OEMs maximize value from returned and excess inventory. Get the strategies you need to navigate the busiest returns season of the year.

Download Now