Nifty can fall to 20,500 in bear case, warns JPMorgan; downgrades Indian stocks to neutral

Wall Street major JPMorgan has become the latest investment bank to downgrade the Indian stock market, revising its rating to Neutral from Overweight and delivering a blow by suggesting that the Nifty could plunge to 20,500 in a bear-case scenario. This implies a sharp 15% drop from current levels, as stretched valuations and uncertainty around the Iran war continue to weigh.

The international brokerage said that while India’s long-term structural story remains intact, near-term tactical headwinds call for patience. The brokerage added that these challenges justify a more cautious stance, noting that although the valuation gap has started to narrow, it continues to remain elevated.

“India has historically traded at a scarcity premium due to its strong growth profile and policy stability. However, that premium is now being tested by low single-digit trailing growth over the past eight quarters,” JPMorgan stated in the report.

“While India’s valuation premium over the MSCI EM index has narrowed to 65% from a peak of 109%, it still trades at a significant premium to peers such as Korea, Brazil, China, Mexico and South Africa, many of which offer cheaper valuations alongside similar or stronger forward earnings growth.”

It flagged multiple risks to earnings, including potential energy supply disruptions, which could impact companies across sectors. Reflecting this, sector analysts have already cut FY27 earnings estimates by 2% to 10% across key segments. JPMorgan has also lowered its CY26E and CY27E MSCI India EPS growth forecasts by 2% and 1% to 11% and 13%, respectively.

The brokerage highlighted that India’s largecap universe lacks meaningful exposure to high-growth themes such as AI, data centres and semiconductors compared to markets like the US, Korea, China and Taiwan. “India is making progress, like startups in AI, big investments in datacenters and chip design centers for global firms, but its presence in these sectors is limited, especially in the large-cap index,” the brokerage added. It also pointed to monsoon-related risks that could hurt rural incomes and drive food inflation.Given the current backdrop, the brokerage sees better opportunities in other emerging markets until valuations correct further or earnings visibility improves. Within sectors, it remains overweight on Financials, Materials, Consumer Discretionary, Hospitals, Defence and Power, while staying underweight on IT and Pharma.

JPMorgan has revised its Nifty 50 targets lower, the bull, base, and bear case scenarios are now 30,000, 27,000, and 20,500, respectively, compared to earlier estimates of 33,000, 30,000, and 24,000.

Earlier this week, HSBC downgraded India to underweight from neutral, marking its second cut in the past two months, citing rising inflation risks driven by elevated oil prices and demand pressures that could weigh on earnings growth.

The ongoing West Asia conflict has brought focus back to downside risks for growth, given India’s heavy dependence on imported energy, the brokerage said in a note. While growth has shown signs of improvement over the past two quarters, we expect the recovery to be delayed from here.

HSBC had earlier lowered India to neutral in late March, pointing to an unfavourable risk-reward balance. Although the March selloff helped ease valuation concerns, the brokerage warned that pressure on corporate profitability could offset this benefit.

(Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views, and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)