Where Should You List Your Rental to Find Tenants Fast

In This Article

Get ready to rumble! There’s an epic fight brewing among real estate portals, with established players facing off against mega-brokerages that are attempting to corner the market and keep exclusive listings for themselves. 

Caught in the tug-of-war are flippers and landlords, wondering where to list their houses and rentals to quickly nab qualified buyers or tenants.

Compass, CoStar, and the New Era of Portal Wars

When it comes down to sheer eyeballs on the screen, Zillow is still the one to beat. However, as HousingWire reports, the recent merger of Compass and Anywhere Real Estate has created one of the largest residential brokerages in the country. Industry analysts say that the firm’s combined scale and emphasis on “exclusive” inventory could reshape the flow of listings across major portals.

Compass’s aim is for consumers to see compass.com as a central destination for listings. As such, the site has been steadily growing a list of private and semiprivate inventory, not available on every rival site.

That move has angered Zillow, which, in April of last year, banned private listings that appeared exclusively on Compass at least 24 hours before they appeared on the MLS. This set off a lawsuit between the brokerage and the listings portal.

It seemed Zillow was getting hit from all sides, because another rival, CoStar, the parent company of Homes.com and Apartments.com, also filed a lawsuit in July claiming that Zillow “stole” and used over 46,000 of its copyrighted property photos to boost its own listings. 

CoStar wasn’t done. The company set out to win over Zillow users by offering to “boost” listings banned by the rival portal.

Google Enters the Fray

As in a scene from Jurassic World Dominion, when a T. Rex is taken out by Gigantosaurus, the same could be playing out in the portal wars. Google has just entered the fray, trialing listings exclusively on its search engine. 

Because of Google’s massive scope, this could prove a major disruptor for Compass, Costar, and Zillow, as viewers will be able to view listings directly on their search engines without having to visit specific websites. It remains to be seen to what extent Google will affect the other listing sites.  

Right now, all the posturing amongst real estate tech’s power players is just that—posturing—because there’s still one clear leader in rental and residential listings: Zillow. However, the race is tightening, and Zillow is not the only option. According to Investopedia’s Best Rental Listing Sites for Landlords and Tenants for 2026, the results were as follows:

According to Investopedia’s analysis, Zillow’s Rental Manager comes out on top due to its large national database, strong site traffic, and integrated features for marketing, tenant screening, and rent collection. Landlords can post a basic rental listing for free in many markets or pay for a premium listing for around $29.99, while renters typically pay a $35 application fee that covers screening reports.

Also included in Zillow’s Rental Manager portal are analytics, pricing guides, tenant screening, a lease builder, online rent collection, and fraud detection systems. There’s also access to professional photography. 

In short, along with a listing on their rental portal, Zillow makes a compelling case for landlords to align with real estate’s online powerhouse.

Zillow’s One-Size-Fits-All Does Not Fit All

However, Zillow’s one-size-fits-all approach does not, in fact, fit all. Investopedia points out that small landlords in smaller markets often have their own methods for highlighting rental listings, and neighborhood-specific categorization is not one of the site’s strengths, especially when tenants are searching by neighborhood or school district.

Hot on Zillow’s tail is its great rival, apartments.com, owned by CoStar, which also owns Homes.com. Investopedia says that the site is best for attracting qualified applicants. It offers many of the same features as Zillow for the same $29.99 price for screening reports and an application, and shows its listings on its own site, as well as Homes.com and ForRent.com.

Social Media: How Smaller Landlords Can Compete

You might also like

Investopedia’s editors recommend using all four portals together to achieve the best overall reach, with Zillow as the anchor platform. 

For smaller landlords, standing out on these sites means competing with heavyweight rental companies such as AvalonBay, Equity Residential, and Essex Property Trust, which have thousands of apartments. It means being nimble and nuanced, competitively priced, and able to offer concessions. It also means leveraging social media platforms such as Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook Marketplace.

Property management platform RentRedi suggests highlighting your apartment in its best possible light with professional photography and staging and using engaging captions and hashtags to attract tenants.

Using a more personalized approach to properties on social media, through Instagram Reels and virtual tours, can be a winning strategy for smaller companies. RentRedi also recommends constantly analyzing performance metrics to see which platforms generate the most user engagement.

Final Thoughts: Beware of Scammers

In the rush to rent your vacant apartment, listing on every rental portal and across social media, be careful not to leave yourself exposed to scammers. According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), $65 million has been lost to rental-related scams since 2020, with Facebook (51%) the most likely place to get defrauded and Craigslist (16%) second.

Scams can take many forms, and it is usually the potential tenant who gets scammed, not the landlord. However, having your apartment used as bait for a con means you have just lost the chance to get an application from a genuine tenant, and you have unwittingly been involved in defrauding an innocent victim.

Ways to deter this from happening include branding every image with a digital watermark (with a website and phone number) so they cannot be used elsewhere, monitoring other platforms with Rently’s Fake Listing Monitoring, and not posting the full address. Because scamming is so prevalent, listing formal photos on major portals rather than on free social media platforms is prudent.