No Result
View All Result
SUBMIT YOUR ARTICLES
  • Login
Friday, October 24, 2025
TheAdviserMagazine.com
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal
No Result
View All Result
TheAdviserMagazine.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Market Research Economy

Caplan’s Experience of Mainstream Economists and My Students’ Surprise

by TheAdviserMagazine
6 months ago
in Economy
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
Caplan’s Experience of Mainstream Economists and My Students’ Surprise
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LInkedIn


 

On his Substack, Bet On It, Bryan Caplan today posted a segment from his newest book, Unbeatable.

The segment is short and so I recommend reading the whole thing.

One key paragraph:

Mainstream economics and free-market economics: Since I’ve long lived in both of these intellectual worlds, I know their inhabitants well. I don’t just know what these two breeds of economists are like now. I know their life stories – or at least their intellectual biographies. Their “neoliberal” reputation notwithstanding, calling mainstream economists “free-market” – or outright “free-market fundamentalists” – is a joke. Few such economists have ever had free-market sympathies. And even though they’ve won a few Nobel prizes, calling free-market economists “mainstream” or even “dominant” in their profession is likewise absurd. Just because your peers cite you doesn’t mean they like you.

This reminded me of something that happened in one of my classes at the Naval Postgraduate School about 20 years ago.

After only my first few years at the Naval Postgraduate School, I took a tack that I hadn’t tried earlier in my teaching. I told the students up front that if we became friends and they invited me to a poker game when the course was over, I would decline because I have the opposite of a poker face. The relevance, I said, was that when I taught, say, the minimum wage, my face would show my upset at politicians who do these things and, more important, my upset at the horrid results. So I owned up the first day to calling my self a small l libertarian. (By the way, the first time I did this, I was shocked when I read my end-of-quarter teacher evaluations. No one commented negatively on my revealing my political bias. To the extent they commented, they said it was refreshing to see someone admit his bias and not put on an act.)

Now to the incident 20 years ago. We were well along in the quarter and I had showed the students why free trade is good for both sides: how rent controls causes shortages and reduces the quantity and quality of housing; why the gasoline lineups their parents experienced were due to price controls on gasoline; how minimum wages priced the least skilled workers out of the job market; and a number of other things.

Remember that my students were military officers who were typically age 28 to 40 and had been around the world. So they had seen a lot of things and were fairly aware politically.

One student said, “Wow, in light of what we’re learning, I bet there aren’t many Democratic economists.”

I answered that I could see why he said that but that the reality was that the ratio of Democratic to Republican and Libertarian economics professors was about 4 to 1.

He was stunned. As I looked around the class, I could see that many of the students were equally stunned. How could this be?

I didn’t have a good explanation. I said that many of them came into economics from math and saw economics as a technical field. They hadn’t gone through Ph.D. programs like mine at UCLA and were involved in typically tiny parts of economics. That’s the best I had. And maybe I’m giving myself too much credit. I know I blamed math but I’m not sure I blamed narrow specialization.

Well, Bryan Caplan nails it. Here’s what he goes on to write:

The biography of a typical mainstream economist starts with a conventional left-wing teenage intellectual from an upper-middle-class home. His parents and school are center-left, but their complacency disturbs him. They pay lip service, while he believes. In college, he discovers economics – and realizes that the world is more complex than he thought. Eventually, the budding economist concludes that a few conventional left-wing views are overstated or mistaken. Support for rent control is a classic example. If you know no economics, rent control sounds like a fine idea: Want the poor to have affordable housing?[i] Then pass a law requiring wealthy landlords to rent at affordable rates. Intro econ highlights rent control’s big negative side effects: shortages, low quality, and dwindling quantity. Politically, though, “a few conventional left-wing views are overstated or mistaken” is normally the end of the line. If you start out as a conventional teenage leftist intellectual, undergraduate economics turns you into a slightly-contrarian twenty-something leftist intellectual.

For most students who fit this profile, admittedly, intellectual curiosity is only a phase. They end up in non-intellectual jobs and turn into their center-left parents. They may even forget that a few conventional left-wing views are overstated or mistaken. The future mainstream economists, however, stay the course. Soon after earning their undergraduate degrees, they continue on to graduate school, where they acquire two new sets of skills.

First, they spend two years grappling with mathematical economic theory. This is demanding material, but too otherworldly to shift grad students’ economic policy views. High theory presents dozens of esoteric ways for markets to fail, but Ph.D. students normally learned all the standard market failures as undergrads. If you’re already deeply worried about imperfect competition, asymmetric information, and externalities, discovering more exotic market failures rarely makes you like markets less. [DRH note: did Bryan mean more?]

Second, unless they become pure theorists, grad students immerse themselves in one or two bodies of ultra-specific empirical research. This immersion occasionally shifts economists’ policy views in their areas of specialization. Yet the maximum effect is small because the volume of research is so massive that most economists end up with no more than a few narrow topics of expertise. In all other areas, mainstream Ph.D. students graduate with virtually the same policy views they held when they started grad school. Minor tweaks aside, that’s where they stay for the rest of their careers. They transition from conventional teenage leftist intellectuals to slightly contrarian twenty-something leftist intellectuals to slightly-contrarian mature leftist intellectuals. Possibly with truly contrarian economic policy views in a few ultra-specific areas they know best. Otherwise, mainstream economists barely connect their life’s work to economic policy. When policy comes up, most take off their researcher hat, and put on their slightly-contrarian left-wing intellectual hat.

At UCLA, by the way, we graduate students had so many ah-hah moments as we learned the material that we started talking among ourselves about this same puzzle. A graduate student who was senior to me, Ted Frech (actually, Harry Edward Frech III) put it well. He said that it almost doesn’t occur to smart economists that there’s a tight connection between economics and the real world. I still remember Ted’s quip: “Paul Samuelson goes home from work and his wife tells him that the price of steak rose by 50 cents a pound; he responds, ‘Shoot the butcher.’”

Postscript: I pointed out where I thought Bryan meant “less,” not “more.” No, he assured me, he meant less. Here’s how he explained it in an email:

My point is that grad school doesn’t make leftist economists more leftist.

 



Source link

Tags: CaplanseconomistsExperienceMainstreamstudentssurprise
ShareTweetShare
Previous Post

Gold tops stocks as second-favorite long-term investment, real estate still no. 1 – Gallup poll

Next Post

PumpSwap hits $100M in TVL as memecoin launchpads see resurgence

Related Posts

edit post
Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected

Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 24, 2025
0

Prices that people pay for a variety of goods and services rose less than expected in September, according to a...

edit post
The Myth of the “Robber Barons”: James Hill versus the Crony Competitors

The Myth of the “Robber Barons”: James Hill versus the Crony Competitors

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 24, 2025
0

Whether we like it or not, the Progressive Era and its mainstream historical interpretation—even when fictional—has virtually defined our last...

edit post
EconLog Price Theory: Pricing Plumbing

EconLog Price Theory: Pricing Plumbing

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 24, 2025
0

This is the latest in our series of posts in our series on price theory problems with Professor Bryan Cutsinger....

edit post
Europe Fears A US Civil War – Whiskey Rebellion To Now

Europe Fears A US Civil War – Whiskey Rebellion To Now

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 24, 2025
0

The Centre for Strategic and International Studies determined that the definition of a civil war is a conflict in which...

edit post
Everyone is waiting for Friday’s big inflation report. Here’s what to expect

Everyone is waiting for Friday’s big inflation report. Here’s what to expect

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 23, 2025
0

A shopper looks at produce at a grocery store in West Milton, Ohio, US, on Tuesday, Oct. 21, 2025. Kyle...

edit post
Reward and Retribution Is the New U.S. Policy for Latin America

Reward and Retribution Is the New U.S. Policy for Latin America

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 23, 2025
0

During the press conference after the meeting with Zelensky, a reporter asked Trump how he would proceed with Venezuela, since...

Next Post
edit post
PumpSwap hits 0M in TVL as memecoin launchpads see resurgence

PumpSwap hits $100M in TVL as memecoin launchpads see resurgence

edit post
I tested the Japanese “Kakeibo” method against the “cash stuffing” trend—one was clearly superior after 60 days

I tested the Japanese "Kakeibo" method against the "cash stuffing" trend—one was clearly superior after 60 days

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
edit post
77-year-old popular furniture retailer closes store locations

77-year-old popular furniture retailer closes store locations

October 18, 2025
edit post
Pennsylvania House of Representatives Rejects Update to Child Custody Laws

Pennsylvania House of Representatives Rejects Update to Child Custody Laws

October 7, 2025
edit post
What to Do When a Loved One Dies in North Carolina

What to Do When a Loved One Dies in North Carolina

October 8, 2025
edit post
Probate vs. Non-Probate Assets: What’s the Difference?

Probate vs. Non-Probate Assets: What’s the Difference?

October 17, 2025
edit post
California Attorney Pleads Guilty For Role In 2M Ponzi Scheme

California Attorney Pleads Guilty For Role In $912M Ponzi Scheme

October 15, 2025
edit post
Baby Boomers Are Flocking to This Florida Town — but Not for the Weather

Baby Boomers Are Flocking to This Florida Town — but Not for the Weather

October 9, 2025
edit post
HKEX CEO Bonnie Chan says geopolitics and economic uncertainty may dim IPO outlook

HKEX CEO Bonnie Chan says geopolitics and economic uncertainty may dim IPO outlook

0
edit post
Why Jana’s partnership with Travis Kelce could tip the balance and revive Six Flags’ business

Why Jana’s partnership with Travis Kelce could tip the balance and revive Six Flags’ business

0
edit post
Tokenized Money Market Funds: Cybersecurity Lessons from the Digital Cash Frontier

Tokenized Money Market Funds: Cybersecurity Lessons from the Digital Cash Frontier

0
edit post
Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected

Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected

0
edit post
Former IndusInd Bank deputy pays 50% of alleged insider trading gains to Sebi

Former IndusInd Bank deputy pays 50% of alleged insider trading gains to Sebi

0
edit post
New Bitcoin Improvement Proposal Aims To Improve Privacy

New Bitcoin Improvement Proposal Aims To Improve Privacy

0
edit post
Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected

Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected

October 24, 2025
edit post
Data Blackout Leaves Fed Guessing Ahead of Rate Decision

Data Blackout Leaves Fed Guessing Ahead of Rate Decision

October 24, 2025
edit post
Microsoft is distancing itself from longtime partner OpenAI, shunning erotica chatbots: ‘Just not a service we’re going to provide,’ AI CEO says

Microsoft is distancing itself from longtime partner OpenAI, shunning erotica chatbots: ‘Just not a service we’re going to provide,’ AI CEO says

October 24, 2025
edit post
Why Jana’s partnership with Travis Kelce could tip the balance and revive Six Flags’ business

Why Jana’s partnership with Travis Kelce could tip the balance and revive Six Flags’ business

October 24, 2025
edit post
New Bitcoin Improvement Proposal Aims To Improve Privacy

New Bitcoin Improvement Proposal Aims To Improve Privacy

October 24, 2025
edit post
Bitcoin: 2,000 Level Emerges as Key Resistance for Next Leg Higher

Bitcoin: $112,000 Level Emerges as Key Resistance for Next Leg Higher

October 24, 2025
The Adviser Magazine

The first and only national digital and print magazine that connects individuals, families, and businesses to Fee-Only financial advisers, accountants, attorneys and college guidance counselors.

CATEGORIES

  • 401k Plans
  • Business
  • College
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Economy
  • Estate Plans
  • Financial Planning
  • Investing
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Legal
  • Market Analysis
  • Markets
  • Medicare
  • Money
  • Personal Finance
  • Social Security
  • Startups
  • Stock Market
  • Trading

LATEST UPDATES

  • Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected
  • Data Blackout Leaves Fed Guessing Ahead of Rate Decision
  • Microsoft is distancing itself from longtime partner OpenAI, shunning erotica chatbots: ‘Just not a service we’re going to provide,’ AI CEO says
  • Our Great Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use, Legal Notices & Disclosures
  • Contact us
  • About Us

© Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved
See articles for original source and related links to external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal

© Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved
See articles for original source and related links to external sites.