No Result
View All Result
SUBMIT YOUR ARTICLES
  • Login
Sunday, October 26, 2025
TheAdviserMagazine.com
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal
No Result
View All Result
TheAdviserMagazine.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Market Research Economy

Useful Counterfactuals on Trade – Econlib

by TheAdviserMagazine
2 months ago
in Economy
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
Useful Counterfactuals on Trade – Econlib
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LInkedIn


Counterfactuals are a necessary part of any scientific analysis: If X didn’t happen, then Y would have.  But counterfactuals, by definition, can never be known.  They never occurred, so we can never truly know if the counterfactual would have happened.  For example, there was much debate in the Truman Administration and the US military during World War 2 over whether or not to drop atomic bomb(s) on Japan.  Some argued that the bombings were necessary to end the war: conventional warfare would cost significantly more American and Japanese lives and continue to drag on the war.  Others argued the Japanese were close to surrender and that the bombings were going to cost more innocent lives.[1]  The debate continues to this day.  But the American military did drop the bombs, with estimates upward of 200,000 lives lost. What we can never know for certain is what would have happened if the US military had never dropped those bombs.

Of course, just because a counterfactual can never be known does not mean that every counterfactual is reasonable.  Counterfactuals have to be justified.  A good theory and model help us justify our counterfactuals.  If I were to say, “without dropping the atomic bomb, the Japanese military would have unleashed Godzilla upon our soldiers, devastating our military, and then invaded San Francisco,” I’d rightfully be laughed out of the room.  That’s a goofy B-movie plot, but not a reasonable counterfactual for historical discussion.  There’s simply no evidence that Godzilla was a tool of the Japanese military.

In international trade discussions these days, the focus is often on the counterfactuals…at least, after protectionists make empirical claims that are easily debunked by the data.  A famous counterfactual revolves around the (oft-cited-never-read) China Shock paper.  If not for China joining the WTO, protectionists claim, the US would be a thriving place, rather than the devastated hellhole it is now.

University of Central Arkansas economist Jeremy Horpedahl recently explored the metro areas hit heaviest by the China Shock (as identified in the original China Shock paper), and he found something surprising to everyone except economists:

[A]ll of the MSAs hit hard by the China Shock still managed to have significant and positive real wage growth across the distribution since 2001…Wage gains in several of these places, in fact, are better than the national trends.

And, except for the Hickory, North Carolina MSA[2], all MSAs have more jobs now than before the China Shock. Austin, Texas has doubled the number of jobs.  The overall economic changes in these areas are rising real wages for all income levels, more jobs, and a growing economy. These changes suggest that trade has been good for the region: newer, higher-paying jobs have entered to compensate for the lower-paying jobs that were lost (as trade theory predicts). If trade were restricted, these better, higher-paying jobs would likely be lost.

But what of the individuals laid off?  Do they lose their well-paying factory jobs and have to take low-paying service sector jobs?  The evidence indicates “no.”  In his 2025 book Crushing Capitalism, Cato Institute economist Norbert Michel provides evidence that displaced workers were not necessarily made worse off.  Using data from the BLS, Michel found that about 43% of workers displaced between 2001 and 2003 earned as much or more than their previous job.  Between 2015 and 2017, that figure was 51% (pg. 70 of the Kindle Edition).  During the China Shock, displaced workers found it easier to find new jobs that paid the same or better.  Looking even further back, in 1991–1992, only about 1/3rd of reemployed workers had pay at or higher than their previous job (ibid).  Furthermore, over two-thirds of people displaced were finding jobs quickly (within a year), and again, those jobs were paying at or better than previous wages.  Since NAFTA and WTO,  it has become easier for displaced workers to find employment at or better than their previous jobs.

So, the relevant counterfactual to compare against increased trade is not that, the US with a thriving economy and protectionism in place.  Instead, the data indicate that higher-paying jobs would be lost in favor of lower-paying, less productive jobs.

 

—[1] There are other arguments, such as retribution for the heinous war crimes the Japanese committed during the war, but this post is about counterfactuals, not retribution, so I won’t be dealing with those arguments.

[2] Hickory could have fewer jobs because the town is becoming a retirement hotspot.  Retired people don’t work.



Source link

Tags: CounterfactualsEconlibtrade
ShareTweetShare
Previous Post

Earnings Summary: TJX Companies reports Q2 2026 financial results

Next Post

TASE launches new financial indices – are they worth tracking?

Related Posts

edit post
Links 10/26/2025 | naked capitalism

Links 10/26/2025 | naked capitalism

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 26, 2025
0

An eucalyptus in bloompic.twitter.com/ID5wvFC9te — Massimo (@Rainmaker1973) October 17, 2025 How the Horse came to be Ridden 3 Quarks Daily...

edit post
The Sunday Morning Movie Presents: Peppermint Soda (1977) Run Time: 1H 40M Bonus: Original Poetry!

The Sunday Morning Movie Presents: Peppermint Soda (1977) Run Time: 1H 40M Bonus: Original Poetry!

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 26, 2025
0

Welcome gentle reader to another installment of the Sunday Morning Movie. Today it’s a tender-hearted coming of age story about...

edit post
US Vs Russia – Greatest Danger Is When A Pawn Thinks It Is A Queen

US Vs Russia – Greatest Danger Is When A Pawn Thinks It Is A Queen

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 25, 2025
0

QUESTION: You said that Trump is listening to the Neocons in his administration and in DC. Would you please name...

edit post
How to Recognize Critical Race Theory

How to Recognize Critical Race Theory

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 25, 2025
0

Reports that critical race theory is over have been greatly exaggerated. CRT is very much still around, although it has...

edit post
A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba

A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 25, 2025
0

In recent years, Cubans have been forced to endure one of their worst shortages of basic necessities, such as food,...

edit post
Links 10/25/2025 | naked capitalism

Links 10/25/2025 | naked capitalism

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 25, 2025
0

This small rural town had 1 veterinarian, a 74-year old veteran who tried finding his replacement for 5 years Even...

Next Post
edit post
TASE launches new financial indices – are they worth tracking?

TASE launches new financial indices - are they worth tracking?

edit post
Lifelines Scented Colored Pencils, 20-Pack only .99 shipped!

Lifelines Scented Colored Pencils, 20-Pack only $16.99 shipped!

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
edit post
77-year-old popular furniture retailer closes store locations

77-year-old popular furniture retailer closes store locations

October 18, 2025
edit post
Pennsylvania House of Representatives Rejects Update to Child Custody Laws

Pennsylvania House of Representatives Rejects Update to Child Custody Laws

October 7, 2025
edit post
What to Do When a Loved One Dies in North Carolina

What to Do When a Loved One Dies in North Carolina

October 8, 2025
edit post
Another Violent Outburst – Democrats Inciting Civil Unrest

Another Violent Outburst – Democrats Inciting Civil Unrest

October 24, 2025
edit post
Probate vs. Non-Probate Assets: What’s the Difference?

Probate vs. Non-Probate Assets: What’s the Difference?

October 17, 2025
edit post
California Attorney Pleads Guilty For Role In 2M Ponzi Scheme

California Attorney Pleads Guilty For Role In $912M Ponzi Scheme

October 15, 2025
edit post
49-year-old favorite pizza chain files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy

49-year-old favorite pizza chain files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy

0
edit post
Skill financing scheme, Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Mudra Yojana, likely to be unveiled in Budget

Skill financing scheme, Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Mudra Yojana, likely to be unveiled in Budget

0
edit post
9 Websites Where You Can Learn New Skills for Free

9 Websites Where You Can Learn New Skills for Free

0
edit post
Kamala Harris expects a woman to be president, and says it could ‘possibly’ be her — ‘I’m not done’

Kamala Harris expects a woman to be president, and says it could ‘possibly’ be her — ‘I’m not done’

0
edit post
High Dividend 50: Chimera Investment Corporation

High Dividend 50: Chimera Investment Corporation

0
edit post
The Sunday Morning Movie Presents: Peppermint Soda (1977) Run Time: 1H 40M Bonus: Original Poetry!

The Sunday Morning Movie Presents: Peppermint Soda (1977) Run Time: 1H 40M Bonus: Original Poetry!

0
edit post
49-year-old favorite pizza chain files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy

49-year-old favorite pizza chain files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy

October 26, 2025
edit post
Skill financing scheme, Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Mudra Yojana, likely to be unveiled in Budget

Skill financing scheme, Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Mudra Yojana, likely to be unveiled in Budget

October 26, 2025
edit post
Kamala Harris expects a woman to be president, and says it could ‘possibly’ be her — ‘I’m not done’

Kamala Harris expects a woman to be president, and says it could ‘possibly’ be her — ‘I’m not done’

October 26, 2025
edit post
‘Protect Yourself From Me Entirely’ — Pregnant Fiancée Says 0K-A-Year Partner’s Prenup Makes Her ‘Legally And Financially Easy To Discard’

‘Protect Yourself From Me Entirely’ — Pregnant Fiancée Says $800K-A-Year Partner’s Prenup Makes Her ‘Legally And Financially Easy To Discard’

October 26, 2025
edit post
Decentralized exchanges surpass  trillion monthly volume as volatility spikes

Decentralized exchanges surpass $1 trillion monthly volume as volatility spikes

October 26, 2025
edit post
How Montenegro became the world’s fastest-growing hub for millionaires

How Montenegro became the world’s fastest-growing hub for millionaires

October 26, 2025
The Adviser Magazine

The first and only national digital and print magazine that connects individuals, families, and businesses to Fee-Only financial advisers, accountants, attorneys and college guidance counselors.

CATEGORIES

  • 401k Plans
  • Business
  • College
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Economy
  • Estate Plans
  • Financial Planning
  • Investing
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Legal
  • Market Analysis
  • Markets
  • Medicare
  • Money
  • Personal Finance
  • Social Security
  • Startups
  • Stock Market
  • Trading

LATEST UPDATES

  • 49-year-old favorite pizza chain files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy
  • Skill financing scheme, Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Mudra Yojana, likely to be unveiled in Budget
  • Kamala Harris expects a woman to be president, and says it could ‘possibly’ be her — ‘I’m not done’
  • Our Great Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use, Legal Notices & Disclosures
  • Contact us
  • About Us

© Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved
See articles for original source and related links to external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal

© Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved
See articles for original source and related links to external sites.