No Result
View All Result
SUBMIT YOUR ARTICLES
  • Login
Saturday, October 25, 2025
TheAdviserMagazine.com
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal
No Result
View All Result
TheAdviserMagazine.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Market Research Economy

A Collectivist Judge Is a Contradiction in Terms

by TheAdviserMagazine
2 months ago
in Economy
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
A Collectivist Judge Is a Contradiction in Terms
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LInkedIn


It is a bit of a mystery why people who claim to be American-style conservatives do not embrace Friedrich Hayek, the economist and legal theorist who was awarded a Nobel Prize in economics in 1974. The mystery dissipates when one realizes that most self-identified conservatives are in fact as collectivist as the self-defined progressives (“liberals” in the confusing American terminology). Each side gives primacy to collective and political choices over individual and private choices, except that it is different collective choices that each side wants to impose. The difference is typically about which groups in society will be favored and which ones harmed.

Let me quote a revealing passage from Hayek’s Law, Legislation, and Liberty (1973–1979; 2021 for the new edition by Jeremy Shearmur), which opposes the common interest of all individuals to each follow his own ends and purposes to an overarching “public interest.”[1] Observe how the quoted passage expresses ideas that are radically opposed to what “the left” and “the right” in the world, Democrats and Republicans in America, believe (to the extent that they believe in anything and, of course, that neither of these two constructed collectives is unanimous). Hayek explains the role of the judge in a free society under the common law (pp. 151–152):

The judge, in other words, serves, or tries to maintain and improve, a going order which nobody has designed, an order that has formed itself without the knowledge and often against the will of authority, that extends beyond the range of deliberate organization on the part of anybody, and that is not based on the individuals doing anybody’s will, but on their expectations becoming mutually adjusted. …

But although the judge is not committed to upholding a particular status quo, he is committed to upholding the principles on which the existing order is based. His task is indeed one which has meaning only within a spontaneous and abstract order of actions such as the market produces. He must thus be conservative in the sense only that he cannot serve any order that is determined not by rules of individual conduct but by the particular ends of authority. A judge cannot be concerned with the needs of particular persons or groups, or with ‘reasons of state’ or ‘the will of government’, or with any particular purposes which an order of actions may be expected to serve. Within any organization in which the individual actions must be judged by their serviceability to the particular ends at which it aims, there is no room for the judge. In an order like that of socialism in which whatever rules may govern individual actions are not independent of particular results, such rules will not be ‘justiciable’ because they will require a balancing of the particular interests affected in the light of their importance. Socialism is indeed largely a revolt against the impartial justice which considers only the conformity of individual actions to end-independent rules and which is not concerned with the effects of their application in particular instances. Thus a socialist judge would really be a contradiction in terms. …

The difficulty many people feel about conceiving of the judge as serving an existing but always imperfect abstract order which is not intended to serve particular interests is resolved when we remember that it is only these abstract features of the order which … can constitute a true common interest of the members of a Great Society, who do not pursue any particular common purposes but merely desire appropriate means for the pursuit of their respective individual purposes.

In short, the role of the judge in a free society has nothing to do with the policy interests of the government or with the personal interests of politicians and bureaucrats, and everything to do with the maintenance of a free society where each individual can pursue his own interests limited only by abstract rules banning some means of action (say, murder, aggression, and theft). But note that this logically condemns not only a socialist judge, but any collectivist judge, whether of the left or of the right, that is, any judge pretending to enforce the supremacy of collective choices. It is virtually certain, I believe, that Hayek would have accepted this amendment.

Note how radical this part of Hayek’s legal theory is. A judge in a non-collectivist (classical liberal) political regime has no role in defending government policy. He only follows and enforces general rules meeting the long-term agreement of a majority of the population and that apply to both private individuals and government agents (except for the government’s power to levy taxes and some other exceptions that I criticize in my review of the third part of Law, Legislation, and Liberty).

A recent court case provides an interesting illustration. The Department of Justice wanted a court to dismiss the case of a policeman found guilty of using excessive force (and on a woman at that!), arguing that the “public interest” is “what the government says is the public interest in this courtroom.” Judge Stephen Wilson, acting like a non-collectivist judge, rejected this argument. From a short review of the decision by Paul Cassell, who argued against the Department of Justice in court (see “The Volokh Conspiracy” in Reason Magazine, August 11, 2025), we may suspect—or hope—that Judge Wilson’s view was not far from Hayek’s distinction between a common interest in the existence of a free society on one hand, and the public interest as whatever the government determine it is on the other hand.

These considerations remind us that the “public interest” as an impossible summation of private interests is either an empty or a contradictory concept. [2] It is tempting to propose a reductio ad absurdum in the spirit of Anthony de Jasay: the state is needed to defend the public interest, and the public interest is what the state decides it is.

******************************

[1] I reviewed the whole trilogy for Econlib, and the third article of my review provides hyperlinks to the other two.

[2] See my EconLog post “What in Heaven’s Name Is the Public Interest?” and my Econlib article “The Vacuity of the Political ‘We.’

 

As an Amazon Associate, Econlib earns from qualifying purchases.

A non-collectivist judge, by ChatGPT



Source link

Tags: CollectivistContradictionJudgeterms
ShareTweetShare
Previous Post

Are Boomer Men Facing a Retirement Crisis No One Wants to Talk About?

Next Post

Taylor Swift sporting ‘cushion cut’ engagement ring gives Signet Jewelers stock a brief pop

Related Posts

edit post
A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba

A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 25, 2025
0

In recent years, Cubans have been forced to endure one of their worst shortages of basic necessities, such as food,...

edit post
Links 10/25/2025 | naked capitalism

Links 10/25/2025 | naked capitalism

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 25, 2025
0

This small rural town had 1 veterinarian, a 74-year old veteran who tried finding his replacement for 5 years Even...

edit post
Market Talk – October 24, 2025

Market Talk – October 24, 2025

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 24, 2025
0

ASIA: The major Asian stock markets had mixed day today: • NIKKEI 225 increased 658.04 points or 1.35% to 49,299.65...

edit post
Coffee Break: Casey Means MD and MAHA, Health Insurance, Coffee Scat, and Big Brother at the Home of the Free Speech Movement

Coffee Break: Casey Means MD and MAHA, Health Insurance, Coffee Scat, and Big Brother at the Home of the Free Speech Movement

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 24, 2025
0

Part the First: Casey Means MD Is Still Awaiting Her Closeup.  We discussed the Surgeon General in waiting some time...

edit post
Five key takeaways from Friday’s consumer price index report

Five key takeaways from Friday’s consumer price index report

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 24, 2025
0

A shopper at a grocery store in Dayton, Ohio, Oct. 21, 2025.Kyle Grillot | Bloomberg | Getty ImagesThe Bureau of...

edit post
Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected

Inflation rate hit 3%, lower than expected

by TheAdviserMagazine
October 24, 2025
0

Prices that people pay for a variety of goods and services rose less than expected in September, according to a...

Next Post
edit post
Taylor Swift sporting ‘cushion cut’ engagement ring gives Signet Jewelers stock a brief pop

Taylor Swift sporting 'cushion cut' engagement ring gives Signet Jewelers stock a brief pop

edit post
What’s the Hidden Cost of Downsizing Too Early in Retirement?

What’s the Hidden Cost of Downsizing Too Early in Retirement?

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
edit post
77-year-old popular furniture retailer closes store locations

77-year-old popular furniture retailer closes store locations

October 18, 2025
edit post
Pennsylvania House of Representatives Rejects Update to Child Custody Laws

Pennsylvania House of Representatives Rejects Update to Child Custody Laws

October 7, 2025
edit post
What to Do When a Loved One Dies in North Carolina

What to Do When a Loved One Dies in North Carolina

October 8, 2025
edit post
Probate vs. Non-Probate Assets: What’s the Difference?

Probate vs. Non-Probate Assets: What’s the Difference?

October 17, 2025
edit post
California Attorney Pleads Guilty For Role In 2M Ponzi Scheme

California Attorney Pleads Guilty For Role In $912M Ponzi Scheme

October 15, 2025
edit post
Baby Boomers Are Flocking to This Florida Town — but Not for the Weather

Baby Boomers Are Flocking to This Florida Town — but Not for the Weather

October 9, 2025
edit post
Ford Motor Company (F) Q3 revenue up 9%; adj. earnings drop

Ford Motor Company (F) Q3 revenue up 9%; adj. earnings drop

0
edit post
What is Schedule K-1?  | Optima Tax Relief

What is Schedule K-1?  | Optima Tax Relief

0
edit post
LendingClub, ABTC surge, Bitfarms, FHI slide: financials wrap

LendingClub, ABTC surge, Bitfarms, FHI slide: financials wrap

0
edit post
I helped design rocket engines for NASA’s space shuttles. Here’s why businesses need AI as trustworthy as aerospace tech

I helped design rocket engines for NASA’s space shuttles. Here’s why businesses need AI as trustworthy as aerospace tech

0
edit post
A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba

A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba

0
edit post
Starboard aims to unlock the value of Fluor’s investment in nuclear tech company NuScale

Starboard aims to unlock the value of Fluor’s investment in nuclear tech company NuScale

0
edit post
A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba

A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba

October 25, 2025
edit post
LendingClub, ABTC surge, Bitfarms, FHI slide: financials wrap

LendingClub, ABTC surge, Bitfarms, FHI slide: financials wrap

October 25, 2025
edit post
Hotstocks KW 43 / 2025 – Solaraktien für mehr Sonne im Depot!

Hotstocks KW 43 / 2025 – Solaraktien für mehr Sonne im Depot!

October 25, 2025
edit post
Insiders Are Scooping Up Shares of a Miner, a Driller, and a Biotech

Insiders Are Scooping Up Shares of a Miner, a Driller, and a Biotech

October 25, 2025
edit post
UK crypto investors face crackdown on unreported gains 

UK crypto investors face crackdown on unreported gains 

October 25, 2025
edit post
I helped design rocket engines for NASA’s space shuttles. Here’s why businesses need AI as trustworthy as aerospace tech

I helped design rocket engines for NASA’s space shuttles. Here’s why businesses need AI as trustworthy as aerospace tech

October 25, 2025
The Adviser Magazine

The first and only national digital and print magazine that connects individuals, families, and businesses to Fee-Only financial advisers, accountants, attorneys and college guidance counselors.

CATEGORIES

  • 401k Plans
  • Business
  • College
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Economy
  • Estate Plans
  • Financial Planning
  • Investing
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Legal
  • Market Analysis
  • Markets
  • Medicare
  • Money
  • Personal Finance
  • Social Security
  • Startups
  • Stock Market
  • Trading

LATEST UPDATES

  • A Brief History of the Enduring American Embargo against Cuba
  • LendingClub, ABTC surge, Bitfarms, FHI slide: financials wrap
  • Hotstocks KW 43 / 2025 – Solaraktien für mehr Sonne im Depot!
  • Our Great Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use, Legal Notices & Disclosures
  • Contact us
  • About Us

© Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved
See articles for original source and related links to external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Financial Planning
    • Financial Planning
    • Personal Finance
  • Market Research
    • Business
    • Investing
    • Money
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Trading
  • 401k Plans
  • College
  • IRS & Taxes
  • Estate Plans
  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Legal

© Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved
See articles for original source and related links to external sites.